Is America stingy with aid?

This blog was actively maintained from 2003-2017. These posts remain here for reference, but some of the content will now be out of date.

There is an interesting discussion going on about whether the US is "stingy" in the amount of aid it gives. US official aid is 0.15% of national income. But some commentators are claiming that this understates American generosity, because of substantial flows of private giving. See, for example:

The facts are collected by the OECD – you can see them here.The offiical figure for US foreign private aid is $6.3bn (table 13 line 26). This means that US foreign assistance, public and private, was about $22.6 billion in 2003, which is about 0.21% of national income, or one fifth of one percent. In dollar terms, this is by far the largest amount of any country. But as a share of income, only Italy provides a lower amount; and the US is tied with Japan and Greece for second-to-last among the industrialized countries. (The figures quoted by Bruce Bartlett are wrong because they include all US financial transactions including investment, bank lending etc). I am grateful to my colleague Steve Radelet at the Center for Global Development for pointing out that the claims about private giving are overstated.